October 21, 2025, Kitchener, Ontario
Posted by: Robert Deutschmann, Personal Injury Lawyer
If you’ve suffered a serious injury in a car accident in Ontario and are pursuing compensation, you may hear about two familiar ideas: proportionate liability and joint and several liability. In simple terms, they’re about who pays how much when more than one person or company is at fault. Here’s what you need to know, explained without legal jargon.
What is proportionate liability?
Proportionate liability means fault is divided among all responsible parties. Each defendant pays a share of the damages that matches their level of fault. If you sue several drivers or companies, the court will assign percentages of fault to each one. Your compensation from each defendant corresponds to that defendant’s fault share, not their entire liability.
What is joint and several liability?
Joint and several liability is the older, “pay it all” approach. If multiple defendants are found at fault, a plaintiff can pursue any one of them for the full amount of the damages, and that defendant then claims the other defendants owe their share to that paying defendant. This protects injured people who might have trouble collecting from all defendants.
Why this matters for your case
- Settlement strategy: If fault is likely to be shared among many parties, a lawyer will push for a fair fault split up front. Proportionate liability can mean smaller exposure for each defendant, which can affect how hard they’re willing to negotiate.
- Recovery odds: In a multi-defendant scenario, joint and several liability can be advantageous to you as the plaintiff if some defendants are difficult to collect from. Courts may still use proportionate liability in many cases, so it’s important to know which approach applies.
- Case value: The amount you ultimately recover can hinge on how fault is allocated. A savvy Ontario personal injury lawyer will examine evidence, expert opinions, and the facts to support a fair fault apportionment that reflects your injuries and losses.
How a personal injury lawyer helps you
- Identify all potentially liable parties: Sometimes more than you realize is at fault, from drivers to product manufacturers or maintenance providers. A lawyer helps uncover everyone who should be considered.
- Build strong evidence: Medical records, accident reconstruction, surveillance, and expert testimony all play a role in proving the level of fault and your damages.
- Navigate rules and changes: Ontario law on fault apportionment has evolved, and the specifics can be nuanced depending on the case. An experienced lawyer stays current and explains what applies to you.
- Maximize your recovery: By aiming for a fair fault allocation and robust documentation of your losses (medical costs, wage loss, pain and suffering, etc.), a lawyer from Deutschmann de Koning Law works to maximize what you’re entitled to.
Why choose Deutschmann de Koning Law
- Ontario-focused expertise: We specialize in Ontario tort claims and understand how proportionate liability and joint and several liability are applied in practice.
- Client-first approach: We listen, explain options in plain language, and tailor strategies to your goals, not just a quick settlement.
- Results-oriented strategy: Our team focuses on thorough investigation, strong negotiations, and, if needed, capable advocacy in court to secure fair compensation.
If you’re navigating a multi-party car injury claim in Ontario, understanding fault allocation can help you make smarter choices and set realistic expectations. Reach out to Deutschmann de Koning Law for a confidential, no-obligation consultation. We’ll review your case, explain how fault might be allocated, and outline a practical plan to pursue the full compensation you deserve.
|